The Cadaver Synod remains one of the most unsettling and disconcerting episodes in papal history, where the boundaries of morality and respect were cruelly tested.
In January 897, Pope Stephen VI orchestrated a trial like no other, exhuming and putting the corpse of his predecessor, Pope Formosus, on the stand.
Formosus, dressed in full papal attire and propped up in a chair, was accused of perjury and violating canon law.
This ghastly spectacle was meant to forever discredit Formosus and solidify Stephen’s power, but it would go on to unravel into a tale of vengeance, political turmoil, and a scathing stain on the Catholic Church.
Setting the Stage for Sedition
Pope Stephen VI orchestrated the infamously dark event known as the Cadaver Synod, placing the rotting corpse of Pope Formosus on trial within the Basilica of St. John Lateran in January of 897. This macabre spectacle took place seven months after Formosus’s death, reflecting the political turmoil that plagued the papacy during that time.
Stephen VI’s motivations were likely to solidify power and discredit his predecessor. The Cadaver Synod marked the beginning of a highly corrupt period in the history of the papacy, often referred to as the ‘pornocracy.’
As the Western Roman Empire crumbled, petty fiefdoms sought to control Rome’s riches and power. The church itself was riven by factions, and aspiring popes sought alliances with secular leaders.
Stephen VI, who’d been appointed bishop by Formosus, might’ve been covering his own political tracks by accusing the dead pope of various crimes. This unprecedented and sinister move by the sitting pope has left an enduring stain on the pages of papal history.
ポぱの転落 Cadaver Synod Proceedings
The formal trial, orchestrated by Stephen VI, saw Formosus’ exhumed body dressed in papal robes and seated in a chair. A deacon was appointed to speak on his behalf, though the deceased former pontiff’s silence was the only response to the bombardment of accusations.
The charges included perjury and violating Church law by occupying multiple dioceses simultaneously. Stephen VI acted as both prosecutor and judge, ensuring a guilty verdict.
The trial was a macabre display of power by Stephen VI, who aimed to justify his own claim to the papacy by delegitimizing Formosus. It marked one of the most bizarre events in the history of the Catholic Church, with the failed attempt to legitimize Stephen VI’s rule ultimately leading to widespread discontent and schism.
Against Formosus’s Legacy
Following his guilty verdict, Formosus’s legacy suffered greatly as Stephen VI revoked his papal decrees and annulled his ordinations. This move effectively nullified all the actions Formosus had taken as pope, leaving his memory and accomplishments in disarray.
The ordinations performed by Formosus were declared invalid, forcing bishops and priests ordained under him to undergo re-ordination if they wished to continue their clergy roles.
This drastic measure is seen by historians as Stephen VI’s attempt to consolidate power and eliminate any potential threats to his rule. The annulment of Formosus’s decrees and ordinations not only sullied his reputation but also created chaos and instability in the Catholic Church.
The ramifications of these actions continued for years to come. Pope John IX, who succeeded Stephen VI, held a synod and declared Formosus’s ordinations valid, undoing the damage done by Stephen VI.
However, Pope Sergius III later nullified John IX’s synod, reinstating the original judgment against Formosus. This back-and-forth has been cited by opponents of papal infallibility as evidence of contradictions in ex cathedra declarations, but these events involved reformable ecclesiastical law rather than irreformable doctrines on faith and morals.
Reversals and Controversy Ensue
Stephen VI’s extreme measures against Formosus sparked further turmoil when his successors intervened, overturning and reinstating verdicts, leading to a series of tumultuous reversals.
Just two years later, in December 897, Pope Theodore II convened a synod that nullified the Cadaver Synod, rehabilitated Formosus, and ordered the reburial of his corpse in pontifical vestments. This was reinforced by Pope John IX, who issued similar decrees and prohibited further trials of corpses.
However, this state of rehabilitation was short-lived. Pope Sergius III, a former co-judge in the Cadaver Synod, reinstated Formosus’ conviction and reiterated the sentence, reportedly going as far as beheading the corpse before discarding it in the Tiber River once again.
These seesawing reversals reflect the intense politicking and factional maneuvers that permeated the Vatican during this period.
The cadaverous trial had become a tool for pontiffs to attack their adversaries and bolster their own power, demonstrating how even the most extreme measures could be employed to settle scores and secure legacies.
In the end, the chaos that followed Formosus’ death left a lasting impact on the ways the Catholic Church handled matters of succession and judgment.
The Crippling Legacy of Vengeance
Pope Theodore II’s attempts to restore dignity to Formosus only served to highlight the long-term consequences of Stephen VI’s vengeance, as the cycle of animosity and retaliation continued to cripple the Cathedral Church.
The lingering effects of this unprecedented act of vengeance persisted, ultimately weakening the pillars of the Church.
Stephen VI’s actions had created a divided and embittered leadership, where every new pope was driven by the agenda to expose and rectify the wrongs perpetrated by their predecessors.
Theodore II, despite his bravery to right the historical wrongs, couldn’t escape the shadow of the Cadaver Synod. His brief tenure and tragic death by murder or natural causes set the stage for subsequent papal reversals.
Pope John IX, aware of the escalating vendetta, diligently organized a new synod to validate the ordinations performed by Formosus and thereby undermined Stephen VI’s verdict. This sequence of actions didn’t bring closure but rather reinforced the chaos that Stephen VI had released.
The tragic legacy of the Cadaver Synod continued to haunt the Church, tainting the reputations of those who’d attempted to restore justice and undermining their positions.
Add Comment